Roland Emmerich is a guy who does big movies, taking steps into the arena with Universal Soldier (Jean-Claude Van Damme AND Dolph Lundgren, plus a just before Law & Order Jerry Orbach) and Stargate and then whacking them out of the park with Independence Day (I have the DVD, should watch it again and do a write up), Godzilla (er, this was a clunker–but a big clunker) and The Patriot (Mel Gibson before he went completely round the bend), you go the whole SF ecological disaster theme, and Dennis Quaid and Jake Gyllenhaal are doing some pretty good work these days so I had hopes when this was coming to theaters.
Sadly The Day After Tomorrow didn’t live up to those expectations, not for me, not at the box office where the $185 million take likely barely covered the production tab, and with terrible reviews and word of mouth I doubt the DVD sales added much more. Which is a shame because TDAT has the blockbuster ingredients but Emmerich got the proportions all wrong. Really wrong in a big way.
Quaid and Scottish scientist Ian Holm (Bilbo himself!) see outsized weather changes which could be precursors of a new ice age, even confronting a Dick Cheney-like US Vice President who sloughs them off as ridiculously alarmist. Then the storms start. Monsters. So big that astronauts up in the International Space Station see them blotting out huge chunks of the nothern hemisphere. So cold that people freeze solid within a couple of seconds’ exposure.
The trouble is that Emmerich stretches every trouble past the breaking point. Some examples:
- Quaid’s wife (Sela Ward) is not just a doctor, she’s a pediatric oncologist, and rather than evacuating with the rest of the patients and staff she insists on staying behind when an ambulance for her eight year old patient–who can’t travel without one–doesn’t come. So Ward sits and reads him a story.
- Gyllenhaal’s love interest (Emmy Rossum) isn’t satisfied with helping a stranded French speaking mom and child as a tidal wave is closing in on them on the streets of Manhattan but after getting them to safety rushes back to the taxi to grab a purse with their documentation.
- Quaid sets off to rescue Gyllenhaal (holed up in the New York Public Library) with his two research teammates. After losing their pickup truck outside Philly and setting out roped together on snowshoes, supply sled roped behind them, the sled crashes through thin ice and pulls a grizzly Jay O. Sanders in as well. Fine, Sanders can cut the rope and release the sled. Is that good enough for Emmerich? Of course not! Sanders has to cut himself loose and plunge to his death too. Puh-leeze!
The whole movie is more or less at this level. No room for subtlety and by ruling that out, any real dramatic tension is out the window as well. About the only thing really interesting or entertaining about TDAT is the computer special effects; to extend a meme, the disaster porn.
not recommended